If you are searching for a real estate agent in Garden City, NY, you are really asking a bigger question: who will make this move feel clear, calm, and well-managed? I’m Meaghan Montegari, a Compass realtor on the Laura Carroll Team, and this is how I work with the people I serve.

Who is Meaghan Montegari?

I spent more than 20 years on Wall Street as an executive before becoming a real estate agent. I’m also a wife, a mom of four kids who each play a different sport, and an Ironman triathlete, coach, and Hyrox competitor. I know what it is to run nonstop, and I know what it is to make a major decision with a lot riding on it.

Why does a Wall Street background matter in real estate?

A home is likely the largest financial decision you will make. Years of financial analysis taught me to look past the listing photos: to evaluate pricing against real comparable sales, to read the numbers behind an offer, and to explain the trade-offs in plain English. You get a professional who is analytical and detail-driven, and who is also warm, kind, and genuinely invested in you.

Who do I help in Garden City and Nassau County?

• NYC relocators: I did the city commute myself before moving to Nassau for more space and a backyard. I understand the trade-offs, from the commute to the neighborhood feel.
• First-time buyers: pre-approval, offers, inspections, and closing explained step by step.
• Move-up buyers: timing a sale and a purchase so you are not stuck in the middle.
• Sellers: pricing, preparation, and positioning based on data.
• Downsizers: a thoughtful, unhurried approach to your next chapter.
• Families navigating a loss: I lost both of my parents, and I understand how a home decision can be tangled up with grief. I will never rush you.

Which towns do I serve?

My home base is Garden City, and I work with buyers and sellers in nearby Nassau County communities including Mineola, East Williston, Carle Place, Westbury, Roslyn, Williston Park, Herricks, North Hills, Rockville Centre, Malverne, West Hempstead, Stewart Manor, Franklin Square, and Manhasset.

What can you expect when we work together?

1. A real conversation first. We talk about your goals, timeline, and budget before we look at a single home.
2. Numbers you can trust. Clear pricing analysis and honest advice, even when it is not what you hoped to hear.
3. Local guidance. Neighborhood-by-neighborhood insight for Nassau County, including my Home Edit town guides for new homebuyers.
4. Steady communication. You will always know what is happening and what comes next.

What do clients say?

Client reviews will be featured here as they are shared. You can also find Meaghan on Google, Zillow, and FastExpert.

Frequently asked questions

How do I choose a real estate agent in Garden City, NY?

Look for someone who knows the local market, communicates clearly, can back up their advice with data, and makes you feel comfortable asking questions. Interview more than one agent, and ask how they would approach your specific situation.

I’m moving from New York City to Garden City. Where do I start?

Start by getting pre-approved, then list what matters most: commute, schools, walkability, yard space, and budget. From there we can narrow down towns and tour homes. I have lived this move myself and can help you weigh the trade-offs.

Do you work with first-time buyers?

Yes. I walk first-time buyers through every step, from pre-approval to closing, and I make sure you understand each decision before you make it.

Can you help me sell and buy at the same time?

Yes. Coordinating a sale and a purchase takes careful timing and a clear plan, and my financial background helps me map out the numbers and the sequence with you.

Let’s talk about your move

Whether you are buying, selling, relocating, or just starting to think about it, I would love to hear your story. Reach out to schedule a no-pressure conversation.

Meaghan Montegari, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson, Compass. Garden City, NY.